Balanced Scorecard: How to set ambitious yet realistic KPIs for success

As a strategy and operational consultant and business mentor, I often find myself discussing with clients the importance of establishing an appropriate level of ambition and effectively tracking their progress.

For start-up founders and entrepreneurs, striking a balance between aspiration and practicality and maintaining focus on their business goals, can often feel like a delicate act. This is where tools like the Balanced Scorecard (BSC), developed by Robert S. Kaplan and David P. Norton in 1992, become instrumental. Not just a framework for large corporations, the BSC is an invaluable tool for businesses of all sizes, especially in dynamic and competitive environments like the UK.

Understanding the Balanced Scorecard

The Balanced Scorecard provides a comprehensive framework that helps organisations translate their vision and business strategy into actionable objectives. It focuses on four key perspectives:

• Financial: Are we achieving our financial goals?

• Customer: How do customers perceive us?

• Internal processes: Are our operations efficient and effective?

• Learning and growth: Are we developing capabilities to sustain future growth?

This holistic view enables businesses to measure their performance against strategic goals while keeping an eye on critical metrics such as profit margins.

Why start-ups and SMEs need the Balanced Scorecard

In my work with founders, I often encounter a common challenge: focusing too heavily on immediate financial metrics while neglecting the bigger picture. While revenue and profitability are crucial, they’re often lagging indicators — reflecting outcomes rather than the causes of success.

Start-ups and SMEs, particularly in the UK, where over 900,000 new businesses were registered in 2023 alone, need to monitor leading and lagging indicators. This ensures they don’t just survive but thrive in an ecosystem characterised by fierce competition, technological disruption and shifting customer expectations.

The BSC is uniquely suited to smaller businesses for several reasons:

• Clarity and focus: It helps start-ups avoid spreading themselves too thin by identifying critical goals across diverse dimensions

• Strategic alignment: Ensures every team member is working toward the same overarching objectives

• Adaptability: The framework can evolve as the business grows, making it a flexible tool for fast-changing start-ups

Watch this webinar to discover techniques and tactics to keep your outlook positive and your business in profit for the year ahead:

Setting ambitious yet realistic KPIs

One of the most challenging aspects of business growth is defining the right types of KPIs that will enable a continuous performance evaluation.

While ambition is crucial for success, it must be met with realistic and attainable targets, hence, careful planning is needed. Implementing well-defined KPIs is crucial for business success. When utilising the BSC, consider KPIs that align with your business objectives across all four perspectives. Here are a few examples you can adopt:

1. Financial

Start-ups and SMEs should focus on identifying the key performance indicators (KPIs) that matter most to their growth and stability. Businesses must establish financial benchmarks to track their performance against competitors and industry standards.

Here are some financial KPIs to consider:

• Profit margin improvement targets: This KPI measures the percentage increase in profit margins over a specific period. It helps businesses track their cost management and pricing strategies, aiming for higher profitability in relation to sales

• Revenue growth rates: This indicator assesses the rate at which a company’s revenue is increasing over time, typically measured on a quarterly or annual basis. A healthy revenue growth rate reflects a company’s ability to expand its market share and enhance sales effectively

• Cost reduction percentages: This KPI quantifies the percentage decrease in operational costs over a defined timeframe. By focusing on cost reduction, businesses can improve their overall efficiency, allowing for better resource allocation and profitability

Taking the time to develop a solid financial strategy enables start-ups to better manage cash flow, attract investors and set realistic revenue targets that reflect their level of ambition.

2. Customer

The customer perspective emphasises understanding and meeting the needs of your target market. For start-ups and SMEs, this can be particularly impactful; establishing strong, trustworthy relationships with customers can lead to brand loyalty and increased revenue. SMEs should prioritise customer-centric KPIs to gauge how well they meet the needs and expectations of their target audience. Here are some vital customer-related KPIs to consider:

• Customer satisfaction score (CSAT): This metric measures how satisfied customers are with a product or service. Usually derived from customer feedback surveys, a higher CSAT indicates a better customer experience

• Net promoter score (NPS): NPS assesses customer loyalty and the likelihood of customers recommending your brand to others. A higher NPS suggests a strong and positive customer relationship

• Customer retention rate: This KPI measures the percentage of customers that continue to use your product or service over a given period. High retention rates indicate that you are meeting customer needs effectively

• Customer acquisition cost (CAC): Understanding how much it costs to acquire a new customer is crucial for managing expenses. This metric reflects marketing and sales efforts and should be balanced against the lifetime value of a customer (LTV)

• Churn rate: This metric measures the percentage of customers that stop using your product or service during a specific timeframe. Keeping this rate low is essential for sustainable growth

• Customer lifetime value (LTV): LTV estimates the total revenue a business can expect from a single customer throughout their engagement with the brand. It helps gauge long-term profitability

By tracking these KPIs, SMEs can gain insights into customer behaviour, preferences and satisfaction levels, allowing them to adjust their strategies for better alignment with market demands.

3. Internal processes

This perspective of the BSC helps organisations identify and improve critical internal operations, such as product development cycles, supply chain efficiency and quality assurance processes. Here are some important KPIs to consider:

• Cycle time: This measures the amount of time it takes to complete a specific process from start to finish. Shortening cycle times can lead to increased efficiency and faster service delivery, which is critical for meeting customer expectations

• Operational efficiency ratio: This ratio evaluates the productivity of resources used in the operational process. A higher ratio indicates that a company is using its resources effectively to produce goods or deliver services

• Process defect rate: This KPI tracks the number of errors or defects in a given process, providing insight into quality control. A high defect rate may indicate the need for process re-engineering or staff training

• Employee productivity: Measuring the output per employee helps optimise workforce productivity and identifies areas where additional training or support may be beneficial

• Cost per acquisition (CPA): This metric assesses the total cost associated with acquiring a new customer, including marketing and sales expenses. Lowering this cost while maintaining quality can significantly impact profitability

• Lead time: This indicator measures the time it takes for a customer order to be fulfilled. Reducing lead time enhances customer satisfaction and loyalty

• Inventory turnover rate: This KPI assesses how often inventory is sold and replaced over a period. A high turnover rate generally indicates effective inventory management, reducing holding costs

By leveraging these KPIs, businesses can enhance their internal processes, ensuring they remain agile and responsive to both market demands and operational challenges. Investing in streamlined processes not only reduces costs but also enhances productivity, enabling businesses to respond faster to market demands and scale operations more effectively.

4. Learning and growth

The learning and growth perspective focuses on the organisation’s ability to innovate and improve. For start-ups, this often means cultivating a culture of continuous improvement and employee development. Here are some examples to consider:

• Employee training hours: Measure the average number of training hours per employee over a specific period. This KPI helps assess the organisation’s commitment to employee development

• Skill acquisition rate: Monitor the percentage of employees who acquire new skills or certifications within a designated timeframe. This indicates how effectively your training initiatives are enhancing team competencies

• Employee engagement score: Utilise employee surveys to gauge levels of engagement and satisfaction. High engagement scores often correlate with better productivity and lower turnover rates

• Innovation rate: Track the number of new products or services developed within a year as a percentage of total offerings. This shows how well the company promotes an innovative culture

• Retention of top talent: Measure the percentage of high-performing employees who remain with the company over time. This KPI helps assess the effectiveness of your growth initiatives and work environment

By investing in talent development, SMEs can foster a motivated workforce that drives creativity and innovation, essential elements for scaling in a competitive environment.

A balancing act

Scaling your business requires a careful balance of ambition and practical execution. The Balanced Scorecard serves as an effective framework to set strategic objectives, measure progress through clearly defined KPIs and keep a close eye on critical financial metrics like profit margins. By adopting this holistic approach, businesses can systematically navigate their growth journeys, leading to long-term sustainability and success.

Ultimately, the level of ambition you set today will shape the future of your business and with the data-driven insights provided by the Balanced Scorecard, you can confidently pursue your goals while keeping profitability at the forefront of your strategy.

How to implement the Balanced Scorecard

Here’s a simple roadmap I recommend to my clients:

• Start with your vision: Define a compelling vision and strategic objectives

• Customise your perspectives: Adapt the traditional BSC categories to reflect your unique priorities. For example, an e-commerce start-up might add a logistics perspective

• Define KPIs: Choose metrics that align with your objectives and ensure they are SMART (Specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound)

• Communicate and embed: Ensure the whole team understands the strategy and their role in achieving it

• Review and adjust: KPIs and priorities may change as your business grows, so schedule regular reviews

Personal reflections: Lessons from my journey

Over the years, I’ve applied variations of the Balanced Scorecard in my ventures and with clients. One of the most rewarding experiences involved consulting for a UK-based health and wellness start-up that was struggling with its overall strategy. It had strong individual initiatives — like marketing campaigns and product launches — but lacked cohesion and alignment across its teams and objectives.

Using the Balanced Scorecard, we worked together to redefine its strategic priorities and align them with measurable KPIs.

For example, from the customer perspective, we identified its ideal target audience and tailored the messaging, which increased customer engagement. From the financial perspective, we focused on streamlining the pricing strategy, which led to a considerable improvement in profit margins. From the internal processes perspective, we enhanced cross-functional collaboration by introducing clearer workflows and reducing project bottlenecks. Lastly, for the learning and growth perspective, we introduced team training programmes and individual performance reviews aimed at empowering employees to contribute to strategic decisions.

This holistic approach not only clarified the business's vision but also energised the entire organisation.

This experience reinforced a valuable lesson: strategy isn’t about fixing isolated problems, it’s about building a connected framework that guides every decision. For founders, especially those managing start-ups, aligning ambition with a clear strategy and actionable KPIs is the key to achieving sustainable growth.

Bringing it all together

Scaling a business is both an exciting and challenging venture. Employing the Balanced Scorecard framework allows owners to maintain a well-rounded strategic focus while balancing their aspirations with practical execution.

By focusing on the four critical dimensions of financial performance, customer satisfaction, internal processes and learning and growth, organisations can set the right level of ambition against achievable goals and measure their progress effectively. Remember, clarity of vision combined with operational excellence is the key to scaling successfully in today’s competitive landscape.

Relevant resources

• How turning customers into brand advocates can benefit your business

• Customer acquisition and retention

• The good stuff: How to set goals for 2025